If you need assistance, please call 800-896-8790

Sanibel

Sanibel Market Report

$1,472,720

AVERAGE PRICE OF 1,206 HOMES

$1,112,129

AVERAGE PRICE OF 14 DISTRESSED HOMES

$2,288,513

AVERAGE PRICE OF 597 MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR HOMES

$3,559,857

AVERAGE PRICE OF 14 NEWLY BUILT HOMES

$1,919,477

AVERAGE PRICE OF 502 HOMES WITH A POOL

$1,158,374

AVERAGE PRICE OF 86 REDUCED PRICE HOMES

Average Home

Average Price $1,472,720
Avg Bedrooms 2.59 beds
Avg Bathrooms 2.33 baths

Average Price by Bedrooms

1 bedroom $465,842
2 bedrooms $699,134
3 bedrooms $1,116,531
4 bedrooms $2,030,370
5 bedrooms $2,460,114
Sanibel Home Price Trends
  2/2026 1/2026 12/2025 11/2025 10/2025
Total Listings 1,184 1,106 1,024 905 753
Average Price $1,496,562 $1,569,026 $1,533,992 $1,493,128 $1,424,360
Avg Price Change -4.84% +2.28% +2.74% +4.83% +1.87%
Median Price $997,023 $1,008,735 $993,722 $982,600 $950,380
Med Price Change -1.17% +1.51% +1.13% +3.39% +0.67%
Avg Bedrooms 2.4 beds 2.27 beds 2.38 beds 2.46 beds 2.53 beds
Avg Bathrooms 2.16 baths 2.02 baths 2.1 baths 2.21 baths 2.35 baths
Home Price by High School
School Name Total Homes Average Price Avg Days on Site
Ida S. Baker High School 1 $1,149,000 34 days
School Choice 40 $1,446,550 88 days
Total Homes Average Price Avg Days on Site
All Homes 1,206 $1,472,720 148 days
Distressed Homes 14 $1,112,129 177 days
Multi-Million Dollar Homes 597 $2,288,513 160 days
Newly Built Homes 14 $3,559,857 86 days
Homes with a Pool 502 $1,919,477 215 days
Reduced Price Homes 86 $1,158,374 127 days